Why we've Come Undone

Cornell Notes

Main Notes

Modern society has experienced an unprecedented cultural breakdown, leading to children transferring attachments from adults to peers.
Economic forces and cultural trends have dismantled the social context for natural parenting and child attachment.
The child's brain is programmed to orient and attach to whoever becomes the working compass point, without inherent preference for adults.
Historically, the natural order ensured bonding between young and adult caregivers until maturity.
In postindustrial society, the environment no longer encourages natural lines of attachment for children.
Factors promoting peer orientation include early placement in childcare, economic pressures on parents, undervaluing of childcare, and lack of attachment education for professionals.
The loss of extended family, increased mobility, and secularization have created attachment voids.
Nuclear families are under pressure due to high divorce rates, marital conflicts, and economic stresses.
Rapid societal changes and technology have disrupted traditional customs that supported adult-child attachments.
Communication technology, while beneficial, can promote peer orientation when left unchecked.
Provençal culture in France demonstrates a society that still honors traditional attachments and maintains customs supporting adult-child connections.
Attachments are formed either as natural offspring of existing attachments or in response to intolerable attachment voids.
Peer attachments formed out of necessity are often indiscriminate and can compete with parental attachments.
Immigration experiences in North America illustrate how peer orientation can undermine traditional cultural connections.
Peer orientation is becoming a global phenomenon as other countries follow the American model.

Cue Column

How has modern society affected children's attachments?
What factors contribute to the formation of peer orientation?
How does the child's attachment process work?
What historical changes have led to attachment voids?
How do economic pressures impact family dynamics and attachments?
What role does technology play in peer orientation?
How does Provençal culture differ in supporting attachments?
What are the two main ways attachments are formed?
How does immigration affect family attachments in North America?
Is peer orientation becoming a global issue?

Summary

This text explores the phenomenon of peer orientation in modern society, where children increasingly form primary attachments with peers rather than adults. The author argues that this shift is not due to individual parental failure, but rather a result of unprecedented cultural breakdown and societal changes.

The analysis traces various factors contributing to this trend, including economic pressures forcing both parents to work, the loss of extended family support, increased mobility, and the rapid pace of technological change. These elements have created 'attachment voids' where children lack consistent, deep connections with nurturing adults.

The text contrasts modern North American society with more traditional cultures, using the example of a Provençal village to illustrate how customs and social structures can support healthy adult-child attachments. It emphasizes that peer orientation is not a natural state but a response to attachment voids.

The author discusses the potential negative consequences of peer orientation, including its impact on child development, family dynamics, and the preservation of cultural values. The text also touches on how this phenomenon is spreading globally as other countries adopt similar societal models.

Overall, the passage presents a critical view of current societal trends and their impact on child-rearing, calling attention to the need for conscious efforts to rebuild and maintain strong adult-child attachments in the face of modern challenges.

← Prev Next →